Following on from last week's Lismore City Council meeting, it would appear that the Richmond River Historical Society (RRHS) will not be returning to its previous home in the Lismore Municipal Building.Cr Jasmine Knight-Smith put forward a motion for Council to offer the Historical Society the space they previously rented so they could operate the Museum and the society from the Municipal building.It was revealed by the Property Services Manager that Council has already entered into three licence agreements with the RRHS for the use of Suites 4-8, the Workshop and the meeting room at the Goonellabah Community Centre, totalling 411 sqm."These spaces support museum displays, storage, and RRHS's ongoing operations," the staff update said in the agenda. "In addition, RRHS was advised of the potential for an extra display area of up to 49 sqm within the CBD library, though they did not express interest."As tenants of the Goonellabah Community Centre, RRHS also has access to the two bookable meeting rooms, with the first two hours available free of charge. When the space was offered to the Richmond River Historical Society (RRHS), they indicated the Goonellabah Community Centre is flood-free and that the overall floor area could be adequate, subject to configuration and adjustments."While staff understand RRHS’s preference remains the municipal building, since signing the agreements, no feedback has been received suggesting the space at the Goonellabah Community Centre is inadequate."Knowing the new license arrangements, it didn't stop Cr Knight-Smith putting forward the motion, in a last-ditch attempt to get the majority of councillors to change their mind and support the move back into the Municipal building. She claims it was "purpose renovated for that very function.""The building isn't just any space. It was upgraded with museum specifications in mind. It includes humidity control, air circulation systems, including underfloor ventilation and other environmental protections designed to preserve delicate historical materials. These renovations were funded by Create New South Wales, with the grant explicitly earmarked for the museum. The intention was clear. This building was to be the home of Lismore's Museum."They only moved out for renovations post flood, and yet today it sits mostly empty. Certainly, where the museum would sit is empty. Putting the Historical Society back in the municipal building isn't just the right thing to do for them; it's the right thing to do for our community.When talking about the Goonellabah Community Centre, Cr Knight-Smith said, "While dry, this space is not suitable. It's too small, not centrally located, and lacks the infrastructure needed to display and protect our city's history.Cr Gordon asked the General Manager if the space was rented out commercially, how much revenue would it return to Lismore Council?Mr Butron wanted to give an accurate answer, so initially took the question on notice, but did say, "The arrangement we've made with the Historical Society of that two-year period is subsidising the Historical Society to be on site substantially."Later, he mentioned the commercial amount would be $80,000 to $90,000 per year after advice from staff.Cr Rob spoke against the motion, saying that he felt as if he was being spanked."It seems every time I turn around, I'm getting hit by someone from the Historical Society. I see them as a political group as well, because when I tried to join, apparently, I wasn't welcome. I don't know why, I just wasn't welcome, not even as a councillor. So it's obviously a, I'm going to say politically left-leaning group, and I'm allowed to say it, because the Constitution protects my freedom of political communication.""As far as I'm concerned, it is the political group trying to demand what they want, and only what they want, and anything else we do is not good enough."Cr Dalton-Earls said he would feel more confident in supporting this motion if the Property Strategy was finalised, so Council had a clearer picture of what assets it owns and where."But it does feel like, out of everywhere that has been identified, that the Municipal building is the right place where they should exist. However, I would like to have seen the property strategy prior, but I also understand, similar with my previous motion, that sometimes timing doesn't always align with when we want to bring things in a meeting."Cr Dalton-Earls also acknowledged the hard work of the volunteers who have operated the Lismore Museum and the RRHS to this point.One area of conjecture raised by supporters of the RRHS concerned a grant it received post-flood to renovate the Municipal building, enabling the reopening of the Lismore Museum and the protection of its valuable documents. Council GM Eber Butron stated that no RRHS grant money was spent on the Municipal building; this was paid for by Disaster Relief Funding and other grant sources.This was challenged by Cr Knight-Smith, who said the Create NSW Grant was given to council for that purpose. "And I spoke to them, and they said the money hasn't been paid back, and it has to be used there or paid back. So what's, where's the money? Just curious.""I asked the same question of my staff who were involved in the restoration of the municipal building," Mr Butron replied, "And I asked the question, had we actually spent any of the funding provided to the Historical Society? And they advised that they hadn't spent that money. So the monies in terms of fitting out the facility were still going to be provided to the Historical Society."Mayor Krieg mentioned that through the negotiations, nothing was ever good enough for the RRHS."Except for the jewel in the crown of the Lismore City Council property portfolio, which just happens to be the Municipal building. Now, we've already heard from the general manager that the approximate costs for the Goonellabah Community Centre is somewhere in the vicinity of $80,000 to $90,000 per year, if that was to be rented commercially, to say that Lismore City Council doesn't contribute to my way of thinking, well, that's a bit of a slap in the face to Lismore City Council."To say, You know what, we're getting a building for free, we can't afford to pay the outgoings, but you pick that up for free for us as well, but we also want the jewel in the crown. There's been no attempt to work with; it's all been demand, demand, demand, and here we are again, after resolving or coming up with a solution, a lease has been signed. What do we do, renege on that lease? Or do they renege on that lease?"I am loath to say this, but to say this isn't political. Well, the Mayor of Lismore, regardless of who the mayor of Lismore is, is actually a patron of the Historical Society, until about three months ago. Now, I'm not going to say why the Mayor of Lismore has been axed, been chopped, been garnered his responsibility as the patron of the Historical Society, but I think I did a damn good job in my two and a half to three years as the patron.""They may have spoken to individual councillors, but certainly not as a collective. I've been trying to get a meeting with the chair for a number of months, to no avail. Yet here we are in the chamber debating this again. I'm not going to support this."In her right of reply, Cr Knight-Smith handed Mayor Krieg a 4,000 signature petition to restore the museum.The vote was 4/7, with Crs Guise, Dalton-Earls, Waters and Knight Smith voting for, and Crs Jenson, Gordon, Rob, Bing, Battista, Hall and Krieg voting against.It would appear that the RRHS will have to be happy with their new home in the Goonellabah Community Centre as yet another motion is defeated.The highly anticipated Property Strategy will be discussed at the next Lismore City Council on Tuesday, November 11, with a briefing session to be held beforehand.